Personalized Attention. Focused On The Details.

Photo of Pamela Epperson
  1. Home
  2.  → 
  3. Criminal Defense
  4.  → 3 ways the Fifth Amendment protects criminal defendants

3 ways the Fifth Amendment protects criminal defendants

On Behalf of | Jun 3, 2024 | Criminal Defense |

The Bill of Rights consists of the first 10 Amendments to the Constitution of the United States of America. Each of those Amendments enshrines certain protections for the public at the federal level. These rights apply to not just citizens but also anyone in the United States.

The Fifth Amendment is one of the most important Amendments for those facing criminal prosecution in the United States. Those facing criminal charges benefit from multiple different protections that reduce their risk of abuse by the government.

How does the Fifth Amendment protect those accused of crimes from government overreach and inappropriate prosecution?

By preventing double jeopardy

One of the most important rules included in the Fifth Amendment is protection from repeat prosecution. Double jeopardy or prosecuting an individual repeatedly for the same exact criminal incident is a violation of someone’s Constitutional rights. Under double jeopardy rules, prosecutors cannot bring charges a second time against someone acquitted at trial.

By limiting self-incrimination

Technically, people have the option of confessing to criminal actions at any time. Those accused of breaking the law can cooperate with the state as part of a broader investigation or while negotiating a plea deal for a lesser sentence. However, if someone decides to defend against pending charges, the Fifth Amendment protects them. While they may need to submit to questioning during a trial, the courts cannot compel them to answer questions that might incriminate them in some way.

Defendants on the stand can plead the Fifth to avoid answering questions that could make them look guilty. Individuals testifying in someone else’s trial or even in the civil courts can also invoke the Fifth Amendment to avoid implicating themselves.

By ensuring the right to a fair trial

The Fifth Amendment also provides the basis for the right to a fair trial. A fair trial requires neutral judges and jurors. The Fifth Amendment also extends the right to a trial by jury, although people have the option of waiving that right in certain circumstances.

Overall, the protections extended by the Fifth Amendment make it easier for people to properly respond to criminal charges. Those who understand the Fifth Amendment can use their rights to achieve a better outcome when accused of criminal wrongdoing.